Well, every editor is going to have writing styles they like and styles they don't like. It's fine to ignore the advice if you don't agree with it.
I do think that she's right in general, though, and that these are pretty good rules to follow. While it's fine to break them for a specific purpose, it's better if the writer knows that they're breaking them -- that they're making that stylistic choice. "Eyes flew" is indeed a metaphor, and once isn't a problem, but I have seen authors basically have characters' eyes doing aerobics with all their movement, and I do think those fics would be better if their authors used that type of phrase more sparingly. But I fully agree that it's a matter of taste.
As for the "said" business, not only do I agree with the blogger, but it is actually one of my pet peeves as a reader. Well, I do think you can snarl words, but some of the others? "That joke was really funny," she laughed. vs. That joke was really funny," she said, laughing. Sorry, but I do think the second version is correct, and the first version is wrong. I don't know, maybe it's just another type of stylistic choice, but it bothers me every single time I come across it.
no subject
I do think that she's right in general, though, and that these are pretty good rules to follow. While it's fine to break them for a specific purpose, it's better if the writer knows that they're breaking them -- that they're making that stylistic choice. "Eyes flew" is indeed a metaphor, and once isn't a problem, but I have seen authors basically have characters' eyes doing aerobics with all their movement, and I do think those fics would be better if their authors used that type of phrase more sparingly. But I fully agree that it's a matter of taste.
As for the "said" business, not only do I agree with the blogger, but it is actually one of my pet peeves as a reader. Well, I do think you can snarl words, but some of the others? "That joke was really funny," she laughed. vs. That joke was really funny," she said, laughing. Sorry, but I do think the second version is correct, and the first version is wrong. I don't know, maybe it's just another type of stylistic choice, but it bothers me every single time I come across it.